Get $2,000 OFF your full roof replacement! Book a free estimate!

Rubber Roof Shingles Problems

Table of Contents


As a home or business owner, your property’s roof quality is of paramount importance — it’s what protects you from various elements like rain, snow, wind and heat. Therefore, the type of roofing material you choose can make a significant difference, both in terms of durability and cost-effectiveness. One option you may consider is rubber roofing shingles. Highly versatile and typically more eco-friendly than traditional materials, rubber roofing shingles have gained widespread acceptance among homeowners and business owners. However, like every product, rubber roof shingles also come with their share of problems. This article dives deep into these issues to equip you with a better understanding before you make your roofing decisions.

What are Rubber Roof Shingles

Rubber roof shingles, also known as synthetic slate shingles, mimic the appearance and texture of natural slate but come with numerous advantages. They are lighter, more durable, easier to install, and environmentally friendly due to their recyclability. Moreover, rubber shingles also have excellent insulating properties, making them cost-efficient in the long run by reducing energy bills.

Common Rubber Roof Shingles Problems

Despite the advantages, rubber roof shingles aren’t devoid of problems. Understanding these issues will help you make a more informed decision about your roofing material choice.

Installation Challenges

The installation process of rubber roof shingles can be tricky. It requires skilled professionals who are experienced in working with this specific material. If installed incorrectly, it exposes your roof to leaks, weakening the overall structure. Consequently, the cost of installing rubber roofs is often higher than other types of roofing due to this specialized labor requirement.

Temperature Sensitivity

Rubber shingles tend to expand and contract significantly with temperature changes. In extreme climates, these changes can cause the shingles to crack or warp, leading to potential leaks or aesthetic issues.


While rubber roof shingles may save you money in the long term due to their durability and energy efficiency, their initial cost is certainly more elevated than traditional asphalt shingles. Therefore, they may not be the best choice for budget-conscious homeowners.

Color Fading

Over time, exposure to the sun can cause rubber shingles to fade, altering their aesthetic appeal. While this doesn’t impact their functionality, it can hamper your home’s overall look.

Resistance to Puncturing

Given that the material is, after all, rubber, it is rather susceptible to punctures compared to other more robust options. This can be a problem, especially on roofs where foot traffic is high or in areas prone to fallen tree limbs.

Maintenance and Repair

While rubber roofs are known for their longevity, they may require more maintenance than other types. Rubber roofs need regular inspections and prompt repair of any punctures or leaks. Although rubber patch kits are readily available, the repair process can require considerable expertise.


In conclusion, while rubber roof shingles do offer numerous advantages, including enhanced durability, cost-efficiency, and environmental friendliness, they also come with a set of challenges that homeowners need to consider. Problems such as temperature sensitivity, installation difficulties, cost, color fading, susceptibility to punctures, and the need for regular maintenance should be factored into your decision-making process.

As a prospective homeowner or business owner considering rubber roof shingles, it’s crucial to weigh these pros and cons and consult with a professional roofing contractor to help you make the best roofing material choice for your unique situation. Remember, the goal is to strike a balance between function, aesthetics, durability, and cost to achieve optimal satisfaction and performance out of your chosen roofing system.

About Roofs By Don

Roofs By Don isn’t just another local Atlanta roofing company. Experience what it’s like to be a star on our own home improvement show. From our personalized customer experience to our quality work, you can’t go wrong with Roofs By Don.

Recent Posts

Follow Us

Latest Videos

schedule a free consultation with roofs by don today