Get $2,000 OFF your full roof replacement! Book a free estimate!

Shingle vs. Shake, Metal vs. Tile: A Punny, Yet Practical Guide to Commercial Roofing Materials Comparison!

Commercial Roofing Materials Comparison

Table of Contents

At Roofs By Don, we know just how challenging it can be to pick out the right roofing materials for your commercial project. It can feel like a grand game of shingle vs. shake, metal vs. tile! That’s why we’ve compiled this practical guide to walking you through a commercial roofing materials comparison. Did you know that, according to the National Roofing Contractors Association, metal roofing can last up to a whopping 70 years? That’s a whole lot longer than the usual 20-year lifespan of traditional asphalt shingles!

Shingle Roofing Is Not to Be Snubbed

Roofing shingles are akin to the reliable tortoise in the classic Aesop’s tale – slow yet steady. They are affordable, easy to install, and come in a variety of styles. Although shingles generally last about 20 to 30 years, this roofing material is relatively low-maintenance, making it attractive for budget-conscious businesses.

Why Choose Asphalt Shingles?

Talk about a cost-efficient and versatile roofing material! Asphalt shingles offer myriad colors and architectural styles, allowing business owners to customize the look and feel of their property. Plus, they’re durable and easy to repair.

Cedar Shake: More Than Just Good-Looking

Sure, cedar shakes and shingles could win a beauty contest against other commercial roofing materials due to their natural, rustic charm. However, this aesthetic appeal comes with a few caveats. In accordance with information from the Cedar Shake and Shingle Bureau, cedar shakes need to be treated for fire resistance. Plus, they must be routinely cleaned to prevent the growth of pesky moss and algae.

The Duties of a Cedar Shake Owner

If you boldly choose the path of cedar shakes, be prepared to maintain the chic and charming beauty of your roof. Regular cleaning, moss, and algae prevention, and fire resistance treatments are your primary roles as the proud owner of a cedar shake roof.

The Might of Metal Roofing

Seeking a Herculean roofing solution? Look no further than metal roofing! The Metal Roofing Alliance has confirmed that metal roofs, being among the most durable roofing materials, can brave the elements for up to 70 years with proper maintenance. That’s like withstanding seven decades of birthdays and general life shenanigans – how’s that for a reliable, long-term relationship?

The Metal Roofing Advantage

Metal roofing is the Superman of roofing materials, with its remarkable energy efficiency and eco-friendly qualities. It can save you some precious dollars on energy bills and also contribute towards sustainable roofing practices.

Tile Roofing: A Timeless Classic

There’s a reason why we can’t get enough of tile roofing, and it’s not just because of its stunning appearance. It’s the roofing material equivalent of a well-aged wine, sparkling with elements of durability, versatility, and energy efficiency. With a myriad of colors, profiles, and styles available, it’s a classic winner in the ring of commercial roofing materials comparison.

Taming the Tile

If you decide to go down the tile road, its initial high cost may make you wince. But remember – a tile roof is an investment for the long haul, offering unparalleled resistance to fire, hail, and even earthquakes.

Consider the Pros and Cons

Investing in the right commercial roof type is a significant decision. Therefore, you must weigh the roofing materials pros and cons judiciously before making your final decision.


What’s the most durable commercial roofing material?

Metal roofs, with their potential longevity of up to 70 years, rank at the top for durability.

Which type of commercial roofing is the most cost-effective?

Asphalt shingles are generally the most cost-effective commercial roofing option.

Are cedar shakes a good choice for commercial roofing?

Cedar shakes can enhance your property’s aesthetic appeal. However, they require significant upkeep to maintain their unique charm.

A Roofing Checklist

1. Understand your business’s specific needs.

2. Conduct a thorough roofing materials comparison.

3. Weigh the pros and cons.

4. Consider the cost and sustainability factor.

5. Keep durability and maintenance needs in mind.

In this grand game of shingle vs. shake, metal vs. tile, it’s important to remember that the best commercial roofing material is the one that meets your precise business needs. Whether you’re guided by aesthetic design, durability, sustainability, or cost, Roofs by Don is here to help navigate your commercial roofing journey!

Remember, choosing a roof isn’t just about finding the best commercial roofing solution, but also about finding a solution that’s best suited for you. So let the roofing games begin!

About Roofs By Don

Roofs By Don isn’t just another local Atlanta roofing company. Experience what it’s like to be a star on our own home improvement show. From our personalized customer experience to our quality work, you can’t go wrong with Roofs By Don.

Recent Posts

Follow Us

Latest Videos

schedule a free consultation with roofs by don today